Sheltered luxury home entry with bronze-framed glass, warm-white stucco, shell-limestone paving and a sculptural sea-grape tree.

Johnny D's Vero Beach Closed: South Beach's Turtle Cove Market

For 15 years, Johnny D's Market & Bistro on South A1A was where you went for a bottle of wine and a quick dinner without dressing up. Vero News described its draw as $22 summer specials and $6 glasses of wine. That building is now closed. Across the road, the same owner has opened a 27,000-square-foot complex whose first business to open was a fine-dining room that OpenTable lists at "$50 and over."

For Oceanridge and the rest of the south end of the island, the grocery side of Johnny D's made it across the street. The cheap dinner hasn't yet.

What closed, and who sent everyone across the road

Johnny D's has posted a note from the family on its website. It says the restaurant "served our final guests at this location" and "will be closed for renovations through October 2027." The note doesn't say goodbye. It sends customers to Turtle Cove Market, "where you'll find many of the foods, wines, and specialty items you already love — along with some familiar Johnny D's faces."

Vero News reported in September that the move was planned that way. Anthony DeChellis owns both the Johnny D's building and the new Turtle Cove complex through Windward Restaurant Concepts. He told the paper that Johnny D's owners, siblings Nina and Mario Amelio, would join the management team at the new businesses. He also said every Johnny D's employee was invited to apply there, and "about 10 or 12" had already been hired. So it's the same family, much of the same staff and the same landlord, with the address moved to the other side of the road.

The complex is at 1410 South A1A, next to the 7-Eleven and directly across from the old Johnny D's. Its restaurant uses the address 916 Turtle Cove Lane. The complex has three parts under one roof: a market, a fine-dining restaurant and a tiki bar. Each covers a different part of what Johnny D's used to do.

The market made it across the road

Turtle Cove Market is the closest match to the old Johnny D's. FSR Magazine's opening coverage lists what it plans to carry:

  • Fresh pasta
  • Seafood
  • Pastries
  • Coffee
  • Prepared meals
  • Specialty groceries

VeroMinute's preview of the complex adds sandwiches, sushi and charcuterie.

Some of that is new for the south end. Johnny D's was an Italian market and family restaurant. Coffee, pastries and sushi make the new market useful earlier in the day and for more kinds of errands. The Johnny D's note says Turtle Cove carries "many" of the wines and specialty items regulars knew, which suggests a good deal of overlap but not a full copy. The market's hours haven't been published in the sources so far. Turtle Cove Market's Facebook page is the one Johnny D's links to.

Dinner moved up a price tier

At Johnny D's, the market and the dinner table were the same room at the same price. At Turtle Cove they are separate businesses, and the dinner room is a much more formal place.

The Blu Fin held its grand opening on Oct. 10 and opened officially on Tuesday, Oct. 13, Hometown News reported. Reservations are recommended. Its OpenTable page lists dinner Tuesday through Sunday, 5 to 10 p.m., with Mediterranean, seafood and Latin/Spanish food. According to FSR, the opening menu started with cured red snapper, lobster, tuna crudo and octopus. Mains included grouper, tiger shrimp, sea-urchin capellini, Iberic pork and steaks, among them a cut called Charley's Steak.

The kitchen is led by culinary director Sebastian La Rocca, who was born in Argentina and has worked at several Michelin-rated restaurants, Vero News reported in July. That makes it a very different kind of meal from a $22 summer special.

Here is how the old building compares with the new complex, using what has been published:

Johnny D's, through its closing Turtle Cove complex, now
Groceries and wine Market inside the bistro Turtle Cove Market, separate business
Casual dinner Family-style, $22 summer specials The Motley Cow, announced but not yet confirmed open
Fine dining Not offered The Blu Fin, OpenTable tier "$50 and over"
Reservations Not described in sources Recommended for The Blu Fin, through OpenTable
Ownership DeChellis building, Amelio family operators DeChellis's Windward Restaurant Concepts, Amelios on management team

Where a casual weeknight dinner goes for now

The third business, The Motley Cow, is meant to fill the casual dinner gap. FSR describes it as an elevated-casual tiki bar focused on seafood, with planned hours of 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Those hours would cover lunch and early dinner, the hours Johnny D's used to serve. No opening date has been announced yet. FSR reported that the market and The Motley Cow would open "shortly after" The Blu Fin. In September, Vero News reported that a delayed equipment delivery was holding up the opening schedule.

Until The Motley Cow opens, a casual dinner close to Oceanridge means heading north toward the 17th Street bridge and Central Beach. Three nearby places run on very different systems:

  1. The Tides, 3103 Cardinal Drive. TCPalm reported that it planned to reopen Oct. 1 after a summer refresh, with an updated menu. The restaurant's website now says it is welcoming guests back and offers fine dining to go. Takeout is the casual way to eat Tides food at home.
  2. Historic Waldo's, 3150 Ocean Drive. Waldo's serves lunch and dinner every day from 11:30 a.m. to 9 p.m., has a bar and doesn't take reservations. Its hours line up most closely with the planned Motley Cow hours.
  3. Ocean Grill, 1050 Beachland Blvd. Ocean Grill serves lunch Monday through Saturday from 11:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. and dinner every night. Dinner names are taken in the lobby starting at 4 p.m., or 3:30 p.m. on Sundays. To eat early, show up and put your name in.

Each of those used to be a drive you chose to make. For the next year, until The Motley Cow opens, it's the default for a casual weeknight dinner out from the south end.

The south end's food map keeps changing

Vero News called this a "dizzying game of musical chairs with island eateries." The new space was first built for The Tides, which then decided to stay on Cardinal Drive. DeChellis then hired his own culinary director, and now Johnny D's is folding into the new businesses.

What reopens in October 2027 may not be the Johnny D's people remember. DeChellis told Vero News that his family once ran a liquor store at the site called South Beach Liquors. Since he still holds a liquor license, the next business there may be a high-end wine and liquor shop. "In a way, it may be back to the future for the liquor store," he said. He also said the plan isn't settled and has no budget yet. He owns the commercial building just south of Johnny D's on A1A as well. He described all these moves as meant to give South Beach "a series of establishments the community can be proud of."

So one owner now controls three neighboring buildings on that stretch of South A1A, and two of them are being reworked within about a year. For Oceanridge, the next twelve months will settle what kind of corner store and weeknight restaurant the south end has. So far, the market is the part that has carried over most directly, with familiar staff and familiar bottles.

Changes like a beloved market closing and a fine-dining room opening next door affect what living on the south end feels like, and that matters to anyone weighing a home nearby. If you'd like to talk about how the South A1A corridor is changing and what it means for Oceanridge and its neighbors, please Get In Touch with Kristin Dobson.

Experience Exceptional Real Estate Service

Work with Kristin Dobson, Florida’s leading luxury real estate expert. With $2 billion in career sales and insider access to exclusive listings, Kristin delivers results with discretion and integrity. Let’s make your next move effortless—contact Kristin today!